The Salary Calculator

Navigating saving accounts in 2023

by Madaline Dunn

Interest rates are going up again, with the Bank of England (BoE) taking its base interest rate to the highest level in more than a decade; this is the twelfth time it’s been hiked. While this means higher mortgage rates and borrowing costs, it should be good for savers, however, UK banks are being accused of short-changing customers.

This week at The Salary Calculator, we’ll walk through how to navigate savings accounts amid the hullabaloo and cover the following:

• Where can savers get better returns?
• Can savers get better returns?
• Should you lock your money in a savings account?
• Is it time to go flexible?

What’s going on with interest rates?

Back in February, the chief executives of the four biggest banks in the UK – Lloyds, NatWest, HSBC and Barclays – came before the Treasury Committee to discuss their low rates. Harriett Baldwin, who chairs the committee, concluded that the nation’s biggest banks need to “up their game and encourage saving.”

Baldwin noted that while other products are available to those who hunt, these banks are offering “measly easy access rates” and further noted that loyal customers are being squeezed to “bolster bank profit margins.” Elderly and vulnerable customers who rely on High Street bank branches were identified as those most vulnerable to what she called the “loyalty penalty.”

Indeed, Which? recently published data from its analysis of three years’ worth of savings rates and found that despite the base rate rising, many high street banks are still offering less than 1% on instant-access accounts.

Indeed, the City watchdog, the Financial Conduct Authority, recently warned banks that it would consider taking “onerous intervention” if savers don’t start to benefit from interest rates.

Can savers get better returns?

According to MoneySavingExpert, anyone with a savings account should not be earning less than 3% interest “at the very minimum.” And, when it comes to rates, Saffron’s new product has been deemed market-leading, offering a fixed 9% interest rate.

However, while this is a great deal, it’s only available to those who have been with the bank for a year or more – ruling out a lot of people. Similarly, Skipton building society is not far behind with its rate of 7.5%. But, again, this deal is only up for grabs to those who joined before May 31st, and allows customers to save up to £3000 a year.

Plus, while these regular savings accounts look attractive, it’s important to note that not all that glitters is gold; there will be restrictions on how much you can pay in, plus, the headline rate is only paid on the first month. After this, you’ll typically end up with just over half the advertised rate.

Should you lock your money in a savings account?

When criticised by the Treasury Committee over easy access rates, Nationwide BS and Virgin Money said the reason banks are more comfortable with higher rates for fixed-term products is that they provide more “certainty and stability.” This is, of course, the attraction of fixed-term rates, you can get more bang for your buck, so to say. Indeed, fixed-term rates are now almost double what they were this time last year. This explains why savers invested nearly £40bn into fixed-term savings accounts in the first quarter of 2023. Plus, by preventing you from accessing your money, you won’t be tempted to dip in.

Some of the best rates right now – at the time of writing – include Tandem Bank’s 5.35% rate, paid over a five-year term, accessible with just £1; National Bank of Egypt, meanwhile, offers 5.25% if you lock up your money for a year, however while you’ll have access to your money sooner, you’ll need to save a minimum of £10,000.

With a global recession looming, however, some suggest that, for the short-term at least, fixed-term deals could be more secure, especially if you’re saving for something in particular that requires a deposit or the like.

Of course, you’ll need to weigh up some of the disadvantages of being locked in. Alongside not having access to your money for a set period of time, when better deals crop up, you won’t be able to switch and make the most of them.

Is it time to go flexible?

Flexible rates have the advantage of letting you take out money when you want to, but you will pay for this benefit with lower rates. Plus, rates are variable, which means that they can either go up or down.

Right now, the top two rates on the market are delivered by West Brom Building Society and Principality Building Society, offering 4% and 3.88%, respectively. However, both only allow two withdrawals a year, so while technically flexible, they are more restrictive than, say, Secure Trust Bank, which offers 3.85% and unlimited withdrawals. Tesco Bank, meanwhile, offers 3.45% with a bonus of 2.45% for 12 months.

Ultimately, your decision should be informed by your circumstances, and you should think about whether you’ll need more flexibility in terms of access.

In an article for The Guardian, a UK Finance spokesperson said that the instant rate market is more competitive, “with a range of fixed and variable rate products available and encouraged customers to shop around for the product and interest rate.”

Tags: banking, inflation, interest rates, saving account, savings